Legal nature of loot boxes under Russian law
https://doi.org/10.38044/2686-9136-2024-5-3-6
Abstract
Currently, the legal nature of loot boxes, as well as issues related to their legal regulation, remain largely unexamined in domestic doctrine. Nevertheless, this topic is of legitimate interest to society, since, as the practice of developers using this mechanism within games shows, opening containers of this type (loot boxes) can be addictive and, in some cases, lead to financial losses. The purpose of this study is to determine the legal nature of loot boxes and lootboxing. Legal doctrine often supports the trend in some european countries to recognize the purchase of loot boxes as gambling and to introduce a complete or partial ban on games with loot boxes. The article, on the contrary, defends the view that the heterogeneity of loot box mechanics in various online games necessitates a differentiated approach to regulation. Dividing loot box mechanics into those that correspond to the legal nature of gambling and those that can be recognized as an aleatory structure only from the point of view of the approach to risk as the player’s psychological attitude to the outcome of the game will allow for the most fair approach to the issue of licensing or non-licensing the activities of developers of such games. As a result, the author puts forward a number of proposals for the legal regulation of legal relations related to the acquisition of loot boxes.
About the Author
A. I. Rusanova
Udmurt State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Alexandra I. Rusanova — Ph.D. student, Department of Civil Law
1, Universitetskaya St., Izhevsk, 426034
References
1. Andrianova, M. A., & Vlasenko, E. V. (2020). Riski provaydera, svyazannyye s neopredelennost’yu pravovoy prirody pol’zovatel’skikh soglasheniy onlayn-igr [Provider risks connected with uncertainty in the legal nature of online games’ terms of use]. Digital Law Journal, 1(3), 21–39. https://doi.org/10.38044/2686-9136-2020-1-3-21-39
2. Arkhipov, V. (2019). Komp’yuternyye igry, “magicheskiy krug” i smyslovyye predely prava [Computer games, “magic circle” and semantic limits of law]. International Journal of Cultural Research, (1), 73–87.
3. Buribaev, T. N. (2021). World of Lawcraft. Voprosy zashchity prav pol’zovateley onlayn-igr [World of Lawcraft: legal protection of online gamers’ rights]. Zhurnal Suda Po Intellektual’nym Pravam, (2), 110–127.
4. Duranske, B. T. (2008). Virtual Law: Navigating the Legal Landscape of Virtual Worlds. American Bar Association.
5. Fairfield, J. A. T. (2023). “Veshchnoye” pravo virtual’nykh “veshchey” [Property as the law of virtual things]. (A. M. Doiev, trans.). Digital Law Journal, 4(3), 16–39. https://doi.org/10.38044/2686-9136-2023-4-3-16-39
6. Fedotov, A. G. (2011). Igry i pari v grazhdanskom prave [Games and betting in civil law]. Vestnik grajdanskogo prava, 11(2), 25–47.
7. Fedotov, A. G. (2010). Natural’nyye obyazatel’stva [Natural obligations]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava, 1(1), 79–131.
8. Kiseleva, L. (2021). Pravovoye regulirovaniye lutboksov v videoigrakh [Legal regulation of loot boxes in video games]. Nauchnye zapiski molodykh issledovatelei, (4), 34–40.
9. Kiseleva, L. (2022). Videoigry kak ob”yekty prav intellektual’noy sobstvennosti [Video games as an object of intellectual property rights]. Obrazovanie i pravo, (3), 93–99. https://doi.org./10.24412/2076-1503-2022-3-93-99
10. Kutovoi, M. (2009). Sootnosheniye obyazatel’stv, vytekayushchikh iz igr i pari i natural’nykh obyazatel’stv [the ratio of obligations arising from games and betting and in-kind obligations]. Aktyalnie problem rossiyskogo prava, (3), 307–312.
11. Lubyagina, D. (2015). Risk v publichnom i chastnom prave [Risk in public and private law]. Finansovoe pravo, (7), 3–7.
12. Pour, S. (2024). The experience of legal regulation of loot boxes in different countries: a comparative analysis. Journal of Digital Technologies and Law, 2(2), 345–371. https://doi.org/10.21202/jdtl.2024.18
13. Savelyev, A.I. (2014). Pravovaya priroda virtual’nyh ob”ektov, priobretaemyh za real’nye den’gi v mnogopol’zovatel’skih igrah [legal nature of virtual objects purchased for real money in multiplayer online games]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava, 14(1), 127–150.
14. Varchuk, A. (2020). Zarubezhnyy i rossiyskiy opyt lutboksov [Foreign and Russian regulatory experience loot boxes]. Voprosi Rossiyskoy yustitsii, (5), 262–272.
Review
Views:
33
Email this article 