dirightDigital Law JournalЦифровое право2686-9136Maxim Inozemtsev10.38044/2686-9136-2023-4-1-28-63diright-132Research ArticleARTICLESСТАТЬИForeign Dissertations on Digital Law: Statistical and literature reviewЗарубежные диссертации по цифровому праву: статистический и библиографический обзорhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-1845-1363ИноземцевМ. И.InozemtsevM. I.

кандидат юридических наук, доцент, доцент кафедры международного частного и гражданского права им. С.Н. Лебедева, главный редактор журнала «Цифровое право»

119454,  Москва, пр. Вернадского, 76

Ph.D. in Law, Associate Professor, Department of Private International and Civil Law, MGIMO-University, Editor-in-Chief, Digital Law Journal

76, ave. Vernadsky, Moscow, 119454

inozemtsev@inno.mgimo.ruhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-1518-6501НектовА. В.NektovA. V.

аспирант кафедры международного частного и гражданского права им. С.Н. Лебедева, выпускающий редактор журнала «Цифровое право» (Digital Law Journal)

119454,  Москва, пр. Вернадского, 76

Ph.D. student, Department of Private International and Civil Law, MGIMO-University, Publishing Editor of Digital Law Journal

76, ave. Vernadsky, Moscow, 119454

artem_nektov@outlook.comМосковский государственный институт международных отношений (университет) МИД РоссииРоссияMoscow State Institute of International Relations (MGIMO-University)Russian Federation202326052023412863Copyright © Inozemtsev M.I., Nektov A.V., 20232023Иноземцев М.И., Нектов А.В.Inozemtsev M.I., Nektov A.V.Данная работа распространяется под лицензией Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://www.digitallawjournal.org/jour/article/view/132

Modern domestic dissertations in law are often criticized for insufficient reliance on previous research. Society’s demand for the study of digital aspects of law, the frequent use of the comparative legal method, and, to a certain extent, the current limited access to foreign sources, necessitate a review of foreign dissertations on digital law. We chose to use qualitative and quantitative methods to select the dissertations examined in this study. Firstly, we selected dissertations defended at universities from the QS World University Ranking. Then, we refined our search by using accessible national and university research repositories. Based on comparative legal and statistical methods, we consolidated the dissertations into a single list and divided them according to different criteria. While doing this, we also defined the main trends in preparing Ph.D. dissertations on digital law. The main results of our study include a subject-thematic index of Ph.D. dissertations in the field of digital law, which is designed to facilitate searches for relevant sources, help researchers determine topics for study, and outline the main aspects of the study of digital issues from the standpoint of various branches of law.

Современные отечественные диссертации по праву нередко критикуются в связи с недостаточной опорой на предшествующие исследования. Существующий запрос общества в изучении цифровых аспектов права, нередкое стремление соискателей в применении компаративистского метода исследования, а также в известной мере ограниченность доступа к зарубежным источникам обуславливают необходимость проведения обзорного исследования зарубежных диссертаций по цифровому праву. Для проведения исследования были избраны качественный и количественный методы отбора диссертаций. Первый выразился в отборе диссертаций, защищенных в университетах, входящих в рейтинг Университетов мира QS, а второй — в поиске по доступным и известным нам национальным и университетским репозиториям диссертационных исследований. На основе сравнительно-правового и статистического метода диссертации были сведены в единый перечень и выявлены основные тенденции подготовки диссертаций по вопросам цифрового права. Результатом проведенного исследования стал предметно-тематический указатель диссертационных исследований в области цифрового права, который призван облегчить возможность поиска соответствующих источников, позволить определиться с темой собственного исследования и наметить основные аспекты изучения общественных отношений в связи с применением новых технологий с позиций различных отраслей права.

цифровое правоцифровые технологииИнтернетдиссертацияпубличное правочастное правоdigital lawdigital technologiesInternetdissertationthesispublic lawprivate lawReferencesBauer, C. (2017). Cross-Buying in the Digital World [Dr. Jur. Dissertation, Universität St. Gallen]. http://permalink.snl.ch/bib/sz001910932Bauer, C. (2017). Cross-Buying in the Digital World [Dr. Jur. Dissertation, Universität St. Gallen]. http://permalink.snl.ch/bib/sz001910932Belov, V.A. (2005). Cyvilisticheskie dissertatsii (1814–2003). Bibliographichesky ukazatel’ [Civil Law Dissertations (1814–2003). Index]. Center YurInfoR.Belov, V.A. (2005). Cyvilisticheskie dissertatsii (1814–2003). Bibliographichesky ukazatel’ [Civil Law Dissertations (1814–2003). Index]. Center YurInfoR.Belov, V.A. (2006). O doktorskoy dissertatsii A.A. Servetnika [On A.A. Servetnik’s doctoral dissertation]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 6(2), 265–283.Belov, V.A. (2006). O doktorskoy dissertatsii A.A. Servetnika [On A.A. Servetnik’s doctoral dissertation]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 6(2), 265–283.Belov, V.A. (2007a). Tipichnye nedostatky dissertatsiy po grazhdanskomu pravu [Typical Drawbacks of Civil Law Dissertations]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 7(1), 272–309.Belov, V.A. (2007a). Tipichnye nedostatky dissertatsiy po grazhdanskomu pravu [Typical Drawbacks of Civil Law Dissertations]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 7(1), 272–309.Belov, V.A. (2007b). O doktorskoy dissertatsii A.E. Piletskogo [On A.E. Piletsky’s Doctoral Dissertation]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 7(2), 271–304.Belov, V.A. (2007b). O doktorskoy dissertatsii A.E. Piletskogo [On A.E. Piletsky’s Doctoral Dissertation]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 7(2), 271–304.Bosch, G.L.C. (2019). Oorlog voeren zonder geweld: Onderzoek naar de regels binnen het humanitair oorlogsrecht voor militaire cyberoperaties die de drempel van aanval niet halen [Waging War without Violence: Research into the rules of international humanitarian law for military cyber operations that do not reach the threshold of attack] [Ph.D. dissertation, University of Amsterdam]. UvA-DARE (Digital Academic Repository). https://pure.uva.nl/ws/files/40249255/Thesis.pdfBosch, G.L.C. (2019). Oorlog voeren zonder geweld: Onderzoek naar de regels binnen het humanitair oorlogsrecht voor militaire cyberoperaties die de drempel van aanval niet halen [Waging War without Violence: Research into the rules of international humanitarian law for military cyber operations that do not reach the threshold of attack] [Ph.D. dissertation, University of Amsterdam]. UvA-DARE (Digital Academic Repository). https://pure.uva.nl/ws/files/40249255/Thesis.pdfCerys, B. (2019). On the Resilience of the Dark Net Market Ecosystem to Law Enforcement Intervention [Ph.D. dissertation, University College London]. UCL Discovery. https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10080409/Cerys, B. (2019). On the Resilience of the Dark Net Market Ecosystem to Law Enforcement Intervention [Ph.D. dissertation, University College London]. UCL Discovery. https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10080409/Core, E. (2020). Value Creation in the Beps Era and a New Approach to Transfer Pricing for Intangibles [Tesi di dottorato, Luiss University]. Iris. https://iris.luiss.it/retrieve/e163de42-a77e-19c7-e053-6605fe0a8397/20200519-Core.pdfCore, E. (2020). Value Creation in the Beps Era and a New Approach to Transfer Pricing for Intangibles [Tesi di dottorato, Luiss University]. Iris. https://iris.luiss.it/retrieve/e163de42-a77e-19c7-e053-6605fe0a8397/20200519-Core.pdfda Silva Campos, M.A.P. (2021). Digital Economy and International Taxation: the digital revolution and its impact on the discourse of international tax law [Doctoral Thesis, Paris 1]. Theses.fr. https://www.theses.fr/2021PA01D020/documentda Silva Campos, M.A.P. (2021). Digital Economy and International Taxation: the digital revolution and its impact on the discourse of international tax law [Doctoral Thesis, Paris 1]. Theses.fr. https://www.theses.fr/2021PA01D020/documentDiver, L.E. (2019). Digisprudence: the affordance of legitimacy in code-as-law [Ph.D. dissertation, University of Edinburgh]. Era. https://era.ed.ac.uk/bitstream/handle/1842/36567/Diver2019.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=yDiver, L.E. (2019). Digisprudence: the affordance of legitimacy in code-as-law [Ph.D. dissertation, University of Edinburgh]. Era. https://era.ed.ac.uk/bitstream/handle/1842/36567/Diver2019.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=yDragomiretskaya, K.Ya., Zabezhinskaya, N.I., & Kyzyatina, V.E. (1962). Sovetskoye grazhdanskoye pravo. Sovetskoye semeynoye pravo. Bibliografiya. 1917–1960 gg. [Soviet Civil Law. Soviet Family Law. Bibliography. 1917–1960] (I.V. Pavlova, G.M. Sverdlova, eds.).Dragomiretskaya, K.Ya., Zabezhinskaya, N.I., & Kyzyatina, V.E. (1962). Sovetskoye grazhdanskoye pravo. Sovetskoye semeynoye pravo. Bibliografiya. 1917–1960 gg. [Soviet Civil Law. Soviet Family Law. Bibliography. 1917–1960] (I.V. Pavlova, G.M. Sverdlova, eds.).Eggersdorfer, L.O. (2020). Filesharing und abmahnwesen [Filesharing and Warnings] [Dr. Jur. Dissertation, LMU München.]. LMU repository. https://edoc.ub.uni-muenchen.de/28286/1/Eggersdorfer_Lars-Oliver.pdfEggersdorfer, L.O. (2020). Filesharing und abmahnwesen [Filesharing and Warnings] [Dr. Jur. Dissertation, LMU München.]. LMU repository. https://edoc.ub.uni-muenchen.de/28286/1/Eggersdorfer_Lars-Oliver.pdfHaward, N. (2018). La reconnaissance constitutionnelle d’un droit à la protection de l’identité numérique [Thèse de doctorat en Droit public, Aix-Marseille]. Theses.fr. https://www.theses.fr/2018AIXM0201Haward, N. (2018). La reconnaissance constitutionnelle d’un droit à la protection de l’identité numérique [Thèse de doctorat en Droit public, Aix-Marseille]. Theses.fr. https://www.theses.fr/2018AIXM0201Herbosch, M. (2023). Intelligent contracting: legal aspects of the precontractual use of artificial intelligence [Ph.D. dissertation, KU Leuven.]. Lirias. https://kuleuven.limo.libis.be/discovery/fulldisplay?docid=lirias-4031921&context=SearchWebhook&vid=32KUL_KUL:Lirias&lang=en&search_scope=lirias_profile&adaptor-=SearchWebhook&tab=LIRIAS&query=any,contains,LIRIAS4031921&offset=0Herbosch, M. (2023). Intelligent contracting: legal aspects of the precontractual use of artificial intelligence [Ph.D. dissertation, KU Leuven.]. Lirias. https://kuleuven.limo.libis.be/discovery/fulldisplay?docid=lirias-4031921&context=SearchWebhook&vid=32KUL_KUL:Lirias&lang=en&search_scope=lirias_profile&adaptor-=SearchWebhook&tab=LIRIAS&query=any,contains,LIRIAS4031921&offset=0Inozemtsev, M.I. (2021). Digital Law: The pursuit of certainty. Digital Law Journal, 2(1), 8–28. https://doi.org/10.38044/2686-9136-2021-2-1-8-28Inozemtsev, M.I. (2021). Digital Law: The pursuit of certainty. Digital Law Journal, 2(1), 8–28. https://doi.org/10.38044/2686-9136-2021-2-1-8-28Inozemtsev, M., & Nektov A. (2023). Subject-thematic index of Ph.D. dissertations on Digital Law (Mendeley data, Version V1) [Data set]. Mendeley. https://doi.org/10.17632/2zsvkhnjwy.1Inozemtsev, M., & Nektov A. (2023). Subject-thematic index of Ph.D. dissertations on Digital Law (Mendeley data, Version V1) [Data set]. Mendeley. https://doi.org/10.17632/2zsvkhnjwy.1Kartskhia, A.A. (2019). Grazhdansko-pravovaya model’ regulirovaniya tsifrovykh tekhnologiy [Civil Law Model of Regulation of Digital Technologies] [Ph.D. dissertation, Russian State Academy of Intellectual Property]. Dissertationny sovet RAIS [Dissertation council RSAIP] https://dis.rgiis.ru/files/dis/d40100102/Karzhia/karchiyaaa_dissertaciya.pdfKartskhia, A.A. (2019). Grazhdansko-pravovaya model’ regulirovaniya tsifrovykh tekhnologiy [Civil Law Model of Regulation of Digital Technologies] [Ph.D. dissertation, Russian State Academy of Intellectual Property]. Dissertationny sovet RAIS [Dissertation council RSAIP] https://dis.rgiis.ru/files/dis/d40100102/Karzhia/karchiyaaa_dissertaciya.pdfKashanin, A.V. (2008). O doktorskoy dissertatsii R.A. Merzlikinoy [On R.A.Merzlikina’s Doctoral Dissertation]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 8(3), 245–277.Kashanin, A.V. (2008). O doktorskoy dissertatsii R.A. Merzlikinoy [On R.A.Merzlikina’s Doctoral Dissertation]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 8(3), 245–277.Khrustalyova, A.V. (2018). Elektronnyye denezhnyye sredstva kak ob’’yekt grazhdanskogo pravootnosheniya [Electronic Money as an Object of Civil Legal Relation] [Ph.D. dissertation, Saint-Petersburg State Economic University]. Presidential Library. https://www.prlib.ru/item/1333298Khrustalyova, A.V. (2018). Elektronnyye denezhnyye sredstva kak ob’’yekt grazhdanskogo pravootnosheniya [Electronic Money as an Object of Civil Legal Relation] [Ph.D. dissertation, Saint-Petersburg State Economic University]. Presidential Library. https://www.prlib.ru/item/1333298Kirsanova, Е.Е. (2021). Pravovoye regulirovanie oborota prav na resultaty intellectual’noy deyatel’nosty v cifrovoy ekonomike [Legal Regulation of Circulation of Intellectual Property Rights in Digital Economy] [Ph.D. dissertation, Lomonosov Moscow State University]. Istina. https://istina.msu.ru/dissertations/351199483/Kirsanova, Е.Е. (2021). Pravovoye regulirovanie oborota prav na resultaty intellectual’noy deyatel’nosty v cifrovoy ekonomike [Legal Regulation of Circulation of Intellectual Property Rights in Digital Economy] [Ph.D. dissertation, Lomonosov Moscow State University]. Istina. https://istina.msu.ru/dissertations/351199483/Krichevsky, G.G. (1998). Magisterskiye i doktorskiye dissertatsii, zashchishchennyye na yuridicheskom fakul’tete universitetov Rossiyskoy imperii, 1755–1918. Bibliograficheskiy ukazatel’. [Master’s and Doctoral Dissertations Defended at the Law Faculties of the Universities of the Russian Empire, 1755–1918. Bibliographic index]. San-San.Krichevsky, G.G. (1998). Magisterskiye i doktorskiye dissertatsii, zashchishchennyye na yuridicheskom fakul’tete universitetov Rossiyskoy imperii, 1755–1918. Bibliograficheskiy ukazatel’. [Master’s and Doctoral Dissertations Defended at the Law Faculties of the Universities of the Russian Empire, 1755–1918. Bibliographic index]. San-San.Lee, A. (2020). International Human Rights Law in Digital Space: an examination of the need for new legal measures for the protection of rights online [Dr. Jur. dissertation, Institut de hautes études internationales et du développement.]. http://permalink.snl.ch/bib/sz991018076629603976Lee, A. (2020). International Human Rights Law in Digital Space: an examination of the need for new legal measures for the protection of rights online [Dr. Jur. dissertation, Institut de hautes études internationales et du développement.]. http://permalink.snl.ch/bib/sz991018076629603976Legrand, P. (2009). The Same and the Different. In P. Legrand, & R. Munday (eds.). Comparative legal studies: Traditions and transitions (pp. 240–241). https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511522260Legrand, P. (2009). The Same and the Different. In P. Legrand, & R. Munday (eds.). Comparative legal studies: Traditions and transitions (pp. 240–241). https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511522260Marchenko, A.Yu. (2022). Pravovoy analys noveyshego zakonodatel’stva ES o primenenii tekhnologii iskustvennogo intellekta [Legal Analysis of the New European Union Legislation on the Use of Artificial Intelligence Technologies] [Ph.D. dissertation, MGIMO-University]. https://open.mgimo.ru/handle/123456789/131Marchenko, A.Yu. (2022). Pravovoy analys noveyshego zakonodatel’stva ES o primenenii tekhnologii iskustvennogo intellekta [Legal Analysis of the New European Union Legislation on the Use of Artificial Intelligence Technologies] [Ph.D. dissertation, MGIMO-University]. https://open.mgimo.ru/handle/123456789/131Michaels, R. (2012). The Functional Method of Comparative Law. In M. Reimann, & R. Zimmermann (eds.), The Oxford handbook of comparative law (pp. 339–382). https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199296064.013.0011Michaels, R. (2012). The Functional Method of Comparative Law. In M. Reimann, & R. Zimmermann (eds.), The Oxford handbook of comparative law (pp. 339–382). https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199296064.013.0011Mochalkina, I.S. (2022). Tsifrovyye prava i tsifrovaya valyuta kak predmet prestupleniy v sfere ekonomiki [Digital Rights and Digital Currency as an Object of Economic Crimes] [Ph.D. dissertation, Lomonosov Moscow State University]. Istina. https://istina.msu.ru/download/507524924/1prx8V:m1Qb0O3w0gEbSUIBO7T-6JogIRKA/Mochalkina, I.S. (2022). Tsifrovyye prava i tsifrovaya valyuta kak predmet prestupleniy v sfere ekonomiki [Digital Rights and Digital Currency as an Object of Economic Crimes] [Ph.D. dissertation, Lomonosov Moscow State University]. Istina. https://istina.msu.ru/download/507524924/1prx8V:m1Qb0O3w0gEbSUIBO7T-6JogIRKA/Muranov, A.I. (2019a). Nekotoryye dissertatsii na soiskaniye uchenoy stepeni, zashchishchavshiyesya v Rossii v 2016–2018 gg. po voprosam mezhdunarodnogo chastnogo prava, mezhdunarodnogo kommercheskogo i investitsionnogo arbitrazha, a takzhe ADR: Kriticheskiy obzor tezisov, vynesennykh na zashchitu (chast’ pervaya) [Some Theses Submitted for Academic Degree and Defended in Russia in 2016–2018 on the Issues of Private International Law, International Commercial and Investment Arbitration as well of ADR: Critical overview of the findings proposed for defense (first part)]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 19(1), 260–319.Muranov, A.I. (2019a). Nekotoryye dissertatsii na soiskaniye uchenoy stepeni, zashchishchavshiyesya v Rossii v 2016–2018 gg. po voprosam mezhdunarodnogo chastnogo prava, mezhdunarodnogo kommercheskogo i investitsionnogo arbitrazha, a takzhe ADR: Kriticheskiy obzor tezisov, vynesennykh na zashchitu (chast’ pervaya) [Some Theses Submitted for Academic Degree and Defended in Russia in 2016–2018 on the Issues of Private International Law, International Commercial and Investment Arbitration as well of ADR: Critical overview of the findings proposed for defense (first part)]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 19(1), 260–319.Muranov, A.I. (2019b). Nekotoryye dissertatsii na soiskaniye uchenoy stepeni, zashchishchavshiyesya v Rossii v 2016–2018 gg. po voprosam mezhdunarodnogo chastnogo prava, mezhdunarodnogo kommercheskogo i investitsionnogo arbitrazha, a takzhe ADR: Kriticheskiy obzor tezisov, vynesennykh na zashchitu (chast’ vtoraya) [Some Theses Submitted for Academic Degree and Defended in Russia in 2016–2018 on the Issues of Private International Law, International Commercial and Investment Arbitration as well of ADR: Critical overview of the findings proposed for defense (second part)]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 19(2), 258–322.Muranov, A.I. (2019b). Nekotoryye dissertatsii na soiskaniye uchenoy stepeni, zashchishchavshiyesya v Rossii v 2016–2018 gg. po voprosam mezhdunarodnogo chastnogo prava, mezhdunarodnogo kommercheskogo i investitsionnogo arbitrazha, a takzhe ADR: Kriticheskiy obzor tezisov, vynesennykh na zashchitu (chast’ vtoraya) [Some Theses Submitted for Academic Degree and Defended in Russia in 2016–2018 on the Issues of Private International Law, International Commercial and Investment Arbitration as well of ADR: Critical overview of the findings proposed for defense (second part)]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 19(2), 258–322.Myskin, A.V. (2016). Sistematicheskiy ukazatel’ literatury po grazhdanskomu pravu [Systematic Index of Civil Law Literature]. Statut.Myskin, A.V. (2016). Sistematicheskiy ukazatel’ literatury po grazhdanskomu pravu [Systematic Index of Civil Law Literature]. Statut.Povarinsky, A.F. (2001). Sistematicheskiy ukazatel’ russkoy literatury po grazhdanskomu pravu, 1758–1904 gg. [Systematic Index of Russian Literature on Civil Law]. (O.Yu. Shilokhvost, ed.). Statut. (Original work published 1904).Povarinsky, A.F. (2001). Sistematicheskiy ukazatel’ russkoy literatury po grazhdanskomu pravu, 1758–1904 gg. [Systematic Index of Russian Literature on Civil Law]. (O.Yu. Shilokhvost, ed.). Statut. (Original work published 1904).Rakhlevsky, V.A, & Borisov, K.G. (1965). Bibliograficheskiy spravochnik dissertatsii na soiskaniye uchenoy stepeni kandidata i doktora yuridicheskikh nauk [Bibliographic Reference Book of Dissertations for the Degree of Candidate and Doctor of Legal Sciences] (V.M. Chkhikvadze, ed.). Irfon.Rakhlevsky, V.A, & Borisov, K.G. (1965). Bibliograficheskiy spravochnik dissertatsii na soiskaniye uchenoy stepeni kandidata i doktora yuridicheskikh nauk [Bibliographic Reference Book of Dissertations for the Degree of Candidate and Doctor of Legal Sciences] (V.M. Chkhikvadze, ed.). Irfon.Robertson, V. (2018). The Challenges of Innovative Markets for Competition Law: a comparative study of the relevant market under EU competition and US antitrust law [Dr. Habilit., Karl-Franzens-Universität Graz]. https://unikat.uni-graz.at/primo-explore/fulldisplay?docid=UGR_alma21338925650003339&context=L- &adaptor=Local%20Search%20Engine&vid=UGR&lang=de_DE&search_scope=Gesamtbestand&tab=default_ tab&query=addsrcrid,exact,AC15367651Robertson, V. (2018). The Challenges of Innovative Markets for Competition Law: a comparative study of the relevant market under EU competition and US antitrust law [Dr. Habilit., Karl-Franzens-Universität Graz]. https://unikat.uni-graz.at/primo-explore/fulldisplay?docid=UGR_alma21338925650003339&context=L- &adaptor=Local%20Search%20Engine&vid=UGR&lang=de_DE&search_scope=Gesamtbestand&tab=default_ tab&query=addsrcrid,exact,AC15367651Rolfes, L.J. (2022). The Legitimacy of Rules of Virtual Communities [Dr. Jur. Dissertation, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin]. https://d-nb.info/1250241421/34Rolfes, L.J. (2022). The Legitimacy of Rules of Virtual Communities [Dr. Jur. Dissertation, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin]. https://d-nb.info/1250241421/34Shamba, T.M. (2000). Yuridicheskiye nauki. Spravochnyy material po dissertatsionnym rabotam za 1994– 1998 gg. [Legal Sciences. Reference Material on Dissertations for 1994–1998]. Ipo Profizdat.Shamba, T.M. (2000). Yuridicheskiye nauki. Spravochnyy material po dissertatsionnym rabotam za 1994– 1998 gg. [Legal Sciences. Reference Material on Dissertations for 1994–1998]. Ipo Profizdat.Shilokhvost, O.Yu. (2007). Cyvilisticheskie dissertatsii (1814–2003). Bibliographichesky ukazatel’ [Civil Law Dissertations (1814–2003). Bibliographic Index]. Izvestiya vysshikh uchebnykh zavedeniy. Pravovedeniye [Bulletin of higher educational institutions. Jurisprudence], 6(275), 230–236.Shilokhvost, O.Yu. (2007). Cyvilisticheskie dissertatsii (1814–2003). Bibliographichesky ukazatel’ [Civil Law Dissertations (1814–2003). Bibliographic Index]. Izvestiya vysshikh uchebnykh zavedeniy. Pravovedeniye [Bulletin of higher educational institutions. Jurisprudence], 6(275), 230–236.Sukhanov, E.A. (2006). O dissertatsiyakh po grazdanskomu pravu [On Civil Law Dissertations]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 6(1), 242–259.Sukhanov, E.A. (2006). O dissertatsiyakh po grazdanskomu pravu [On Civil Law Dissertations]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 6(1), 242–259.Sukhanov, E.A. (2015). Ob otraslyakh prava i ikh sistematizatsii v avstro-germanskoy pravovoy doktrine (kratkiy obzor fundamental’nogo truda) [On Branches of Law and Their Systematization in the Austro-German Legal Doctrine (a brief overview of the fundamental work]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 15(2), 295–302.Sukhanov, E.A. (2015). Ob otraslyakh prava i ikh sistematizatsii v avstro-germanskoy pravovoy doktrine (kratkiy obzor fundamental’nogo truda) [On Branches of Law and Their Systematization in the Austro-German Legal Doctrine (a brief overview of the fundamental work]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 15(2), 295–302.Tretyakov, S.V. (2008). O doktorskoy dissertatsii V.L. Tolstykh [On V.L. Tolstykh’s Doctoral Dissertation]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 8(1), 243–264.Tretyakov, S.V. (2008). O doktorskoy dissertatsii V.L. Tolstykh [On V.L. Tolstykh’s Doctoral Dissertation]. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava [Civil Law Review], 8(1), 243–264.Ulbrich, C.R. (2021). Die Überwachung lokaler Funknetzwerke (“WLAN-Catching”): Informationstechnologische und strafprozessuale Aspekte unter besonderer Berücksichtigung allgemeiner Fragen der Internetüberwachung und Verschlüsselung [The Monitoring of Local Radio Networks (“WLAN-Catching”): Information technology and criminal procedural aspects with special consideration of general questions of Internet monitoring and encryption] [Dr. Jur. Dissertation, Universität Zürich]. http://permalink.snl.ch/bib/sz991018837431203976Ulbrich, C.R. (2021). Die Überwachung lokaler Funknetzwerke (“WLAN-Catching”): Informationstechnologische und strafprozessuale Aspekte unter besonderer Berücksichtigung allgemeiner Fragen der Internetüberwachung und Verschlüsselung [The Monitoring of Local Radio Networks (“WLAN-Catching”): Information technology and criminal procedural aspects with special consideration of general questions of Internet monitoring and encryption] [Dr. Jur. Dissertation, Universität Zürich]. http://permalink.snl.ch/bib/sz991018837431203976Weinrib, E. (1988). Legal Formalism: On the immanent rationality of law. Yale Law Journal, 97(6), 949–1016. https://doi.org/10.2307/796339Weinrib, E. (1988). Legal Formalism: On the immanent rationality of law. Yale Law Journal, 97(6), 949–1016. https://doi.org/10.2307/796339Zelger, B. (2021). Infringements in EU Competition Law and the Digital Age: A critical analysis of the meaning of ‘effects’ in the establishment of prima facie infringements of Article 101 and 102 in light of the impact of changes in the economic environment and reality due to digitization [Dr. Jur. Dissertation, Universität Innsbruck]. http://media.obvsg.at/AC16589959-1001Zelger, B. (2021). Infringements in EU Competition Law and the Digital Age: A critical analysis of the meaning of ‘effects’ in the establishment of prima facie infringements of Article 101 and 102 in light of the impact of changes in the economic environment and reality due to digitization [Dr. Jur. Dissertation, Universität Innsbruck]. http://media.obvsg.at/AC16589959-1001

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.